CCMtg07-09-01WSMinCI"" 1 -11' IIIICI
\'(10l) M, 16
". LII
.. . ....
P, I P'aI I
.1J. l,,.F" C,Adk��,,-),
Ocrddinc Znm"'. C ." Ol
'Ll, 10 ORDI 11.
............ . "I"
IT(I S" () N . I 111 r 1: 1 1 1 11 ( "I I I I I , 10, k" ll ll "1111 1., F 11
MI'll, 11 I'll ON 1 1-1111(
--,d ,-1 il . . .... ..... . .
P.-IN I fl, I ', d" P., "Cm "' Cpk % t,'
111-11 L1(11 SuPM1 v PA., Fmm H", dz' P— " C,i I
11�, ll,lk,�, --d i. a h, I PC 1- ,k .,d ,,d 11- .., ..... ...... w be 11,,iM, lh,r Jairo m -" the C, , , , " " ", " il"
sh, -d 11— look 1,,, , -1 1 Pn> 1 ,1 cand
I M� 11,", FPC , I'll,,, . , 1) ll" Im" ,, I ". — ':""'s
Mr. Drato expininai his concerns .� ilh the su:lion sided, f,rorrA \�ahons, and
l icvul Swlion n... superpuous in Ina: he did no: belie., n frcnch'ae
for shordJ he par: ofa proclsiou :hzt n pnwm eompany..roukl :tie inb, h, o
levera_c ilscll I'el,li.-c to con. ,d bel-I :he mle slnicwic should he the Sc}'
romponen, unJ :he livnchise ftt Ji.�orced Crain thv:li,tcs should be:ha
In icsponsc 11 Commissions, Iliill,,'1, 1 aylar said :hc old nprsemcn: "I only
n :. puges lon_lund'il provided for"'I':o ha,e:he livnehise and l he fors .:nI
pm\dded the option :o purchase. Then ,re a numheiof:hinos in the Imposed
2e. hesid, the lack of dle option :o puaha", :ha: ere o�jec:ianabl,,
II .. il, l he , .11 n 8n pas::11h,1 I o to purehuse l,l I lh,: being
ei:hnr the City dcciAes sotto main:.nn Ihn: oVlion. or FPC ullu..s ,hc Iurch,sa
Cum...... nor slitli,' ""'ti,r sunhat eeplvnal�on „n the chunyes i n:he
proposed agreement. AYha: makes it nl:dl �.hannukes h'—P
%la— Loves:r,ncI asked ifromcone11 florid, po.ver:vouIll explain.
17r'favler edviscd h,m l'om Cloud. of 0 ", limits end IZoiinsnn, the Cnv s
�r Lo. m:d lmlerl laj that tie—, scon1a-11 he m. of ,k,, this ..'ork
en hm could have npwl lime nperw,ids. al another wo swh, " Mayor
lnresnnml and Ail'. T,Ylor dtlwlad Mr. Cloud'x in.'olvclnenl in tit mcr:ln4.
Commiss:oncr Bendy asAl if:hc Commission .\ns here :o nceo:i,:e,. i:h FIC
Comnnssloner Bundy a, of the opinion :hot an\nine the ngCemmission,v,s
.'.d'm litigation :.'ith soinwnc:hey..ere negwi.11i.rilh, they should ha'a
input fmm the Altomey mpmscnling them in ti,l liti��tion if the anomey has
anything Icnincnt w say.
said he..vnhl nnempl to,ns.vc' Commissioner hiller s Im'sli
saying if FPC stets imo,n ,yrrentent..-i lh t, fandI frn-d
Ciuomhs Jo..i, the mod enters inla an a�mr .'l:h anothev c, lobp%.the
v onld gtl the e.�lnt percent.Astor.iatNnief,l linnehisc lcc �.�slhut
.auld ie nhnl�!ed. \ir. Dr,¢n m'iJ he dtnuuht it wlus h'Y.
Ms. Simluon reyucstvd eddi..sing spine of the issues brought up. she t.pinined
mat htowwad nmions dunaea name above �, ms,dt orm>r...... s
,vhh 11 Rnrcnl cities and is bi-hu.7,l. haring protection faith, CITY and f r IK
She evplainM lhm soli n,Aaddresses prmncuon forlhc clues Asti result nl
\Air. Di,go t.anlinga brondnFv.'ored N,lions proteclion.IhcY :hen subsequently
CC ]tll 11I\I60
I I'd Ihrovder npn1-III,,Sac nl J-11,11,1 P-111.1, ],,I FPC, ,,d, as
I—., "1, ,,11. �I " Oh, 'i 0,1, ,, " ;,y if I I—" I , ." ,,
In rspon oIm,1 111 111,-, ,id A III,-, I I
clan.,du, - U4, I."I III'. 'I'd -I N." III,
d" d—d" - 1, I—d a a �:� nol �- �I'-
'd, I I,,— r
11h1—TIh, Fa— Xa,ioics clvuseshou Id
Ntill,7 d 1, he
11
......I ng,I, I-,, 1", f
,Ifi . ih, iI Ice. P(I,,, dk�d,,,,,. rixhr
"i" "Id" p I", ih, favored 1 , ,,1: 11-1111", I'll
I,"-.
.. ... . I — III— f- 11" bl" I .. ............. . III, nanom I "', a,
a,,,,IW In Ilk I ..... I ,.L--d RIC -k :I, [ .... ... ....... I- W
Then 4nomd Dom, n(,ha per Nii
11", 1 PI , I, —km�, h, h, diraion of Impmeins the
D"I", If,— lk,I.,,, yaes,ianed if,, FP( di-- m
D, I IL "'II,1 lla",.'d , ,, "I"'-d , ,, --, I'd
Alm',. 1z", " , , -,W, I aI,k,d 0,1 1 PC -,, , ,, 2, 1.,1 1,1
.�— d I I, II,, f II III, -1d I I Id Iff-I of
FP( .
%1,, SdI,,j-,,, I ph,d 111"I I,, "'I I,, no db— 1. oppro,mg
...... . ... .... .
lo, -d,
11"s —I -.11io-d mine of,h, "0"
........... ..... d mi,g"i'd 'y ...... ....
Depu,y,�Iuyor a-lain_o, no,ed CPC won,"he eilies, cup mO ly'_h,s l,"
City ,vpmsen,s ihv ycoPlc... ,o look after their in,errs,s.4 and ,hc C'hy has asked
tai nn ulu�s�on in oidu ,o Ini Ih„ lvplum.
Commissioner Anderson cri,iq,i' Sec,ion 7. A. 13_ end C oiler which he -said ,vi,h
Sec,ion l.A. as a pan ofd,e d,,--,,. ,hem „-as no nxd for Soc,'ion 7 A. B or C.
Can,inissioner Handy discussed wha, S--, 7.A.p -ild.saying;,„ssaone-
,,.�� shy„ in t PC's li,vor.
Nuyor Lovcs,rand saiA we naw hova ...........
and n,unicipalicelion „'oulJ be
the only,ray ,hiz„ould he alien'.
Comn,isioncr Bundv disagreed, rayiny,he Ci,y,vould be al I'ec,cd ifdemgula,iou
c.nne about n'_ d,cralorc, believed d,e Fa,' —,I Nations clause should not be in
Dquny kla3ror klaingoi coocmxed —I, C'on,m issioner aundy_
As,o whemer eno,hcr n,ili,y company could come in and ,ue [PC's eyaipmen,.
1As. Simpson said no, a„liis lime as them are Icmul a.Tenxen,enls; ho„'ever.
m me even, of dcrev}dmlou or omerchnuges, it Is Possible Ilra, Omer pinvidcrs
Cmmnissi l-Bandyasked fFPC w-ould, antler,he Favomd N,nions dance
ollc''a highor Innd,isc foe 1lanomer company came in and oIT the cnp n
er fee. As hts. Sm, rospon nil, he snfd i, app—,,l
II eans,ver„gas no ant Ihcmfom_suy�ealeJ,he I �omd N,Iions clans, he
Con,inissioncr Anderson, uher amain discussing pa,aguphs ]. A. R and C,
__ -d S-,fo, 7 A be dropped. sappy i, ,oily does not providca
believed S'n, , l3 vnd Coniv Provide liabili,y,o the Oily and,
sherc s,ed all of S-m,l7 be delaled. Biscussian con,'inu' „yid,
especl to manovl,� A only, or A B nutl C.
\"w, Lova'ir1-i ask' iI Scniou ;could I ov'sad, lhc,n have a
pr, .1-1 inchid',vh I,, fianchise,ould bo n ,-d for _ ,ii-iC
Nis Simpson said a renpencr....visian had b—, Indbm ,ves ,cmov,,
mquecl of Mr. Dn,go. n1s.S'ui,..son again ludN ' m tl
iis�t,sion abou,,hc Fevored
Nations clause.
con - nneo�sno anyye�led aplaang s�do�� y �eiln i,ndnag.• d�m,aya
me c�y..�li�d�oegenud«I. udlid¢s �sd�me some ale-anmrorm l�nnonae
ree-,na a, e.ue me rn�-dncid��,l �� d�al�ne Inc rl'nnehiae r t Ir own he
IimW. Commiaioner.\ndcn'mnr�iL4M1 odlica� ni ll�c �t�Aitol'ncsoF lu
�� heihcr �hi� made sense front n ci�nnnclual poim ofvier saying he undas�ood
FPCs concern us �h��Annr�phis hug Ane��' �hnl FPC+eere �rcntinn ii ns
on. ol'dseircoss and derceieed II'vsn clisdraninge.
In �esponsc to Cssiona Anderon.\Ir_ Tnvlor said he oM1'icluf io usin_ she
and rene olinled and explaimvl his He 11,11k. dnot imdersinnd
hr 7 A 1r'ar bums consldeiul liar ianovnl, 11, li and C hcilln Ich ill. ar I1n» ,\
— the onl r item thal wdd Ihmniicvlly li.ror the Cl�v niW H and C could onl.
Coissionc' I d�-n,Ye—llanpnn3c saving lhm all fraucl�isu�rocs ImpaseJ
GIs. Simpson svid she coidd eenninly �n4c ihrl pmpos�l back io FPC. She did
indlen�esomc concen�:ibom the unii-Inisl ivuu, ill ihd 1=VC �r'onld be u�re
olhcc militia a nuld M1c chnl'ecel in the C'n v. IJisnlssion ensiied:ls w hors'
Ihslnn uuld he �•nrduL
Asio n reopcncr elnnsc, hls. Sinilsson rend the rsnpcnei clunse Isom the Ins1 dill
�fthe I�anchis.: g —,"I uiid suit siic ��'ould not liv�'c o pcohlcm pmtin_ it hac4
in the loon.
Air. Di vgo r�vd "I ill Io hl , h ,h i1h, d Ihis pa......l.h be lukc�i om-
\ir.Ikx�os"nidhe�honI, ithod �o do ��ilhthe dcvcy+ulmion isniz. U1d111, on
rimed uhcc �HsicM1 Atr. Dr:lyo Ihrn read the pal ug�apli and crldniliL his
n, Parliculurl r', ��i�h Iungnne�Ihal Icynired n�ttlimi�n �hroudh the coons in
Irincllas Conn�v.
Con.micrioncc Handy l-'I the IanAuaye could he slmplilicd.
Con cr 'fill In the fact Ihur the Cdv —,Id hair 1,1 gu
o the .'off os Io gel aPpNr'ad Ie ecpcnd lim , to pmchuse the i.01, V:nurr'inss
mie. and hmv rcmom It rr'ould hr f0! "MI a mfteendnm m puss. gmsllonml n by
FPC �rould n� _ o pm she Pnrchnse option in the _ in.ni
M, Simpo vid Ihis hich is uull. rani n and it
polio posi�iun Ihm FPCJeould rim tierce to e pmclluse provision becnusz FPI s l
�eAl in selling ilx sysicn�..md to include the pros'ision rs'oulJ imply they'
ienunreds
Con�missinncr hlillcrimpressed on MI s. Sithe vole.,,-ld ncacr
approc'e sucha purchase and FPC shoal) not f rpuain_ Thal cn
Mayor Lorrslcaad said L.,,V oclhas su ecicd thalolw��'cr
ould rnise the lnorlxa5e in51�ad of the City but said he
i mfanable �vhh lhai ys he did not hclicee the Commi1h,, oald dcle.aic
pono.rs it did no�hare iou power canmisson- HP ugraed lhn�ihe possibililvof
c��-na or loans, say+os al in rr.a,<hi.. rcer. �.hi�n aia nor in�wdo ma I<s�l
Commisioner dundv said he would nol vole for un aeremcm ill did nol hm,c
did nol couhnn the P,, hll— oplion. He helleced t he optimi to Purchase,vas
hnlcal in hui it provided the on ly laver.;c the Ciiy has . hold `PC acaiuniablc
prodding sale. reliable snviea. 14'ilhou��hc parchase opl'ion. Long�r-ooil
ould be glnn�iu: a permancm Ranehise. He wun�ed �o muin�ain lha� righh nol
loi us. but liar lhase who come adenr.irzls.
yleyor LoresaanJ sad you haresaid you do not rani, to a....-ipal-,, lhcri wliy
pike and he did nnl venal to have ibis panieular provision lib ou�'vs he rrvs
lookia_< .for the bear lnlems�s of11" public
Con Anderson undelsiaoJ a niapll1J f Nc Commission had ecpmssed
lh'is ���ns ofceniral concern_ and FPC, enncem is Ihal lhcy do r the Cay
tnAiap their customers_and ihni this is fPCsle and cusromen. However_
he believed iha�nc� ci�izccis of Lngwood have ei.1 clivfPC the privilege ofsening
.lien'. I'PC sabsarip", vofsialcandin aal:aowle, Ilkn 1 of drvi.has
bee_ iIIPCiha_ vheriaha or JOreamw ile @e sole procidcrof
cor' HCntl vhal hPC is nor�-snyi2 is shot ai the rnd of 30 v�rs siden�s
rheir alsmmax and it is illeir property_not the ciliuns al' Longwood or n,dr
cpmsen�aiir ea eu�. the original conaac�raiJ the Ci�y has she riyhi w�emiinaie
rniplisl�.11 would l�ar'e io be appn�red by the vo�crFFlCdoes no11lI to
,circa c'vVricious r� hinr_hc:ai h�Ihat simple. Ax c Commissioner Muller has
,.lid. l I rsould Imra w be lbc recall �ofdlc cinsne.clog angry. being dishdc:u11
r-ilb Pre :r�miaa odor nl nke nsha,dn ad doe mhkedebl. venal
o onrrn to t r I nm<na rnamra�m hesiE„s o end ofma
l�n„��anos nn� :dm�r- na me l;gb� �n a�a��ge renan�r. n,en lh�-renal,, is in aarga. I
uny n.ort. F"I , ,,k,ny li,r nn —1,-i n,onoPol.:
fore.cr.Sho,dd dn'egnlafion ce�r I..PPen. m,ha-dofd,is 311y v1. uchlse.,he
Ch.•s onlroPeoa �.m.iv„�P:,yah, and „gain dna ognh,. co.amission,,
.lnddrson said hd bclieacd if Il.c Parch:i.d op,ian clans.:..'... in them lhd Cil�
.. o.dd sissn ,h�apreanrn,_
\9s......... ........ wCni er �ndor .Plni _..1,y
,hcy ha,'c.nadc.he Puh.. daci�,1 no. olld.'mg'C' -"I".e ap,ion.
o,henI.... in. cc,men, of mil lions afdolla in.o 0"ri21Ns-of-..'sl s. us,.ell a5
d...nP..... dh as WuiPn,e.... .,' .V.F S..nlssun also men,ioned ,hu, Flwida
ho...... al n,ensi.c lh�po..cr hasinesh.�us. Inrc.Ponsc to nyairy. she
caPlaind s,randud ros.s, ..hich urcinacn.nu„s n,ada based an unlicip;.ldd
Co.nmissioncr.—,,,,, dip,aI,d thes,,.,l.,l cos,s. Ha.'r-,.mphesiidcl 11-.hc
hr ached. men mt ,duf.he ..hndAn vhem
dbew m m,00ad.n�h.� dds.��.-.ansd �no�.�own��..
� �no.�e dc ,o.,�,� �Ir�,�
,,,FPC. He Indd,ha. PPC ,. _ - o
hR l'11°I.n_ o I dd ak, acl 'n11,
hoGcral .ha, .aas very iai.' m I'PC and hr rould no, .ice uP on Ne Pivple's ri,dn
,n a,ahe ma, enni��
II;n- Lowcamadsaid.bacd an Commissioner Audcrson s d..na.....
aPPcared,here..-.ds an i n,Pa ,
�i.h Commissioner Andcrso.t rv?in Ilhe yad nPut.o the y,op leand
,he�'tur.i �1 it do..n,.vhdr...a.dd.,che, .,oti.i She,1111-Ii, ,,'11, he.i I,rabFll(
,I I dol lur rul,v'cnd,..n P,,srul by 510home.. Ilea ds,'I FPC'
j,es. �s,dp I.ec4: and IooA :.y:hn PI .I,is, as'h could n,�.-dr happdn, and jus Pu. ,hd
op.ion in.
Gls. 5anpson svi I FP( o ddal l 1,,11 I,h n11 oC.he 111ic. and t1l"I vecuy,cd .ha,
Pesi,ion for Long...... Ihea ,.odd Ic P... in,h.: Position of nigo.ia,iny d,a, sam.�
o,hcr..,.ia-
Din sud..1,I,,,�Pdc,.o some ci,ies dha--11 loss.1-1ufi%frandhial
d. Commissioner IIill7'said 1t appra.'s Ih—are rvme.Mr, nccs as 111, FPC
do.dd lld- .nc dlffcrcnl ly I, l.n ,oI
Ik Simpson mmin,. J ,o esPlain FPC's ra,ionulc
N r.liYlor. ye a pui.,. of infunau.ian, aJ, -d .ha, in me 01, of 11., 1land. FPC'
did ca,znd ,ha - n,..n„�i.h .ha p..rch:u oPu nPm..s.nn_
i+l, Lor'-,,,d rallied the amount of the City seas losi ne by noI
ring rhev and poinlad to 'nd,111mg Allamonre Spnn@d, 1110
ntd the age Lint are nenIe ci4Llhair liannhisc lnon.Y anrC Ycr.
Lon�rrmod choesesnio sia ll and lusv rlenionev. \1 s. S inipson l,,ml,d ro the
orb by Las Cnlccc Commissioner �tillcr said uhiniaidly Long—W
oSl ld rein. as diJ tas Cruces. Ma. Sinll+son disputed Coninri uioner ylillar's
srereln�nl Thal l:,is Cruces rr on.
Canim irsioner Miller again reiterated lhar he balic�N Long��ood ��-erdd siyr the
II anehise i f the brlyroui provision rr'uc suet udcd.
Daqul� Mawr Maingut, looking for a...nipronrisc. , Acd If FPC —dd be
enable if Longwood ere ro ag— ro a Iive Ycar conhver , W, IYC. ry ioh rh,
i of nc� hrly orir clause, hni I ision included in this eonn:Icr Ill.,
Islikq nrl ayrenneln. Loncrr uod could nlnxraru that buy our clause or
l dog ikr II. In usher rrroNs, xe am nor closing; the door on the opporin oily
Commissioner dundysxid he rvordd not rare WO" frvnchise a_sreem�'nr ��-irhoul
tho brly our clause.
Mayor Iareslnnd agahi proposed si@nili_ the agreement without the buyorlr
Comnilssio. Andcrmn said there arc rlma rrM1cr it costs to nand up and do
ri Jrt, Ic did noI holier c the C'onnnissiun wes hcin¢ obslinalc.I
helievcs srendine on princip le is"ally'imponwn. \4 eaec bei "a,Udro give ap
rho people s choice hrr_ood. And. FPC wanu to protect their honour Ilnc. nc,h
spending the laepuycrs'nioney foolish lv. I.., yr the logical coneluson_.goin_
say rye wal n FPC to pay Ihal C, nchise fee and the Coup
mYVPC Irv" Io pay �uinl nn ugreslneni is ruched II is n.Insoludort Thcy
will say pus until von neaori lig a pace- Soil die Ciry wins the I'nsr V"h the
Cit�rvill rhea o fightrhe whole thing. Ind. he IF lnor het, dre
people would vole ro alryn1ove going Fnh rrirli the Purchase. Furthannore, —
CcmmLssioneiAndn'son dissu'ivd saving be Thought it n-as very imponum
Mayor vivcsl rant mid Yoa arc asking t he coun Ill say Yon cvn keep rho Ill
y II don't wool Ia buy h.
C1.1111. 11,1, 1 d11 011 s
Mayor la, anJ said ,, did nni I.,- ,,, 11, "faylor haJ asked the
d 11 1 k,,., FIA
Cloud npnned Iha, ,he )nd�c in Oronec County rulad ,ha, -PC has to
...... ... ,he
sou do have au alrrn:nivr io bovine. you hacc an
Ih . .... .
Iceol
N, TI, i, i, 1, ""imo in 1,,,, of clhics in Flodda.,chioh ,�t,�Il�ezrmo in aeposfu'on. von haves emery sound
"0 -�, �,il �"",
I qucs,ionz us h, had done
.... pointed
AJministrator,vhn I,es r�panisr in arras Ilia, none of the ..........
....... ...k ad,i-and
A,,-,Ih— ,dkg not ,ak, 11,6 ad, i,,
D,,, IM llzll 11, A,-1 ,,,,,kl iu f ....... . . . ..... . .
.. ........ I
"I ,111 C1,11-, 4 I I fill, ,k, I
I Hill, said she
,nd he n lined ,k 1* Jillrren,
issues..... -, "" nears he
does been in
""' I � o, h, , He, ", ,, I I "