BOAMin09-06-89Bt1ILDING OFFICIAL FL RNANO TIELIER
PLANNER
1. Mrs. Su ber called the meeting to order at ].3U P.M.
2. Approval of Minutes of July 19, 1989 and august 2, 1989:
aav isea the E and e listenea t
tha towhat He had thought he as aid i had hb aidddu~ing
a i.acueeioo. tatea h has s but
woula like to reserve enem u„cii Aaaitio~ai doiscuasio~oltemss
o by M roll, e
istri9s9 ana~A ucea ae ry~emic tea. apMOtion Carriea
by a unanimous roll Call9 BVO[e.
ARIANCF. REQUEST TO C RUCT A PRIVATE
TO eOUR SINGLE F NLOTS. LICANI':
ERSI eiED NR AL CSTATE S(W. P. WOOQ). LOCATION. O%FO RD STREET.
aoNiNG R-IA.
Suber d y d proof of publication for all po bl is Hearings
on [he Agendas pl
xea if aayoaa p of the
re¢~escbe ooa e sieeac pot ko sieiea weal
aoaMw aN here c aic eof t ooa
eea ne naa a dopy oieat o from Piao~ioga r~gara n~g Mena
ae~siey C ooa e tea h ana M Jami out ana
lookaa a on,e ra o aena ixy ana ei a to be an avy o
aoa ooiye o
subject p and tney a e look adng t make
required asquare f rage advised t
Board ht eed ed i my f
Oepar[ment aw the only o hat h e farha
ing paved and tha tsH ople w e City o
before a ewpricei of t ou la
ey535U eogo/$ZOO PooU aran ge a t
be ve ryhb neficial. t aty. pa othe
project would meet eve yeCitygcodehwith the exception of tnetroad
wi.d tH.
tetl h n favor of t request and further
t edUt wof Adjustment could n t give a
it would be contra ryrdt'o se ri ion ]oU of Che C y Code but could only
end t e City C the only o who
had the right to grant the va r.vance. No one else p sent spoke for
the va_van ce.
sober a ked if anyone p bed t speak against t
ioosn oxford s tea ne c
~epxio~ c vxningES ery a xea io~ts~with m ena~
e yrandfat he.reaMi and w eabu ilt before z and
rope rty h e behind i nadv~ised
andowner knewoue ctly wha tt theNZ inq w
Emoryts pt edst t land owneracoula put a other boos eso
red. ePa M ooa has h
e land es .ingent u rthe Sv
react ntne ara
eighborhood Ch rs p.iec es
ofaproperi yf 1 and r ulae open uB ae Pandora's box.
teat the rene ing
ember y theao s paid h ha den Ding f
aeyxeat a of em ney for the slam ur e further s teasTbe re 1
o bards hip no ood o t landowner.
nhe City just he ldW.i ing o e Comprehensive
Plan and guidelines w early s trying t
than Thos uidel
andmt dr iyhtsr ifrt
s granted ~a srproperties o i.lamere. orysw
if he spoke foz eothe rs > eighborhnoa. as howko£
hands i the audience inflice ting tbaY they egreedr wit hsM Dry.
cry a tad an ao' raalua i regnirea a end and of the a~i.ve,
Loper w as ks for a tea he and has
neighborsdes trong ly recommend the request be den ieaa
Meltzer spoke against t request. Meltzer s [ed
thatM heva ember of the ~ ted a the r _ t Lorathe
mple r mof vt being a substanaa rda road. ted if the
ity a
ould c or same thing in ehe neighborhood as we 11 as
throu9 out the Ce tYn f
Eed upon t
ondi~ctea a an dsi e ae as adty ri a lti[tle
rappearedY using the
property tapprais er's r old require
n depths vey T e howl manyts ucturetl a e living u
tea as far a wilamere x
typefo
Nagle t
Nagle of ut etiny ~
ked w ie91.a a foruo roes
requesting t
i.n9 h veY ~ ing t egPro Pe rtYdaPPraase rs
records and wrote the a g std31 te1989 memo. Mr. agle referenced
attachment [ t 31, 1989 m icn w color c
hags p ial for oDe.ing subd ividetl.
d Dased o today, i appeared s Mof
aeaiexesma l aena.ieias w ewnat
niynerrc Hater inq oraiaan~e w pia allow t a milt coaay.
Nagle s uolook a what i
ua Sly the re edgran tibn gt the v
t be a adverse as his m tea e °esa et8w1
that c pluses thet applicant's eprope rtys
approximately 2 the Oxford and
Wildmere uA Nagle furihero s tetl traffic impact
directly approximately lOtat rps per day per
ave ge s g e fam ilylhous e.
arlyn Piloian spoke against the request s inq s
ildmere f agora rty o
h 1 1/2 a applied ab and i
denied. m Smdit D, 909 Oxfnrd1ld
inq he bought t of quality ofg Sandi
in g. Jameshe
opposed t Mthe r and g ba ge rs d be u
pro
atyn fi ~e hm
ould adestroyal'.hew character of etnem neighbor oodt, i
t hyt5 spoke against t inq s Heel a
a~doa lotmana s area if this variance was grant edhthen she would
also like one.
Su ber allowed M a three m buTtal, ood
red t s far as dens aty, [he Plannang 0 kind
ought [ ooperate, and i r ethismrequest w
e aensicv t tea c
inq ith MS tea dhet has o
in gls familylu ands later bought i e duplexes o
property. ood s red M and
also question ed`V the appropriateness n ember,
atldressing the i
ory and M ood u and M ory s red uh ked is ibtytA Hey
if t Had a onf lict of I ood had ns rated, apart he
CityeAetorn ey had assuredn him he did Hof.
Public Heari g losed.
Heel Coat if g red a
abl is heae a
grandT inbg tc hip o epplican chat
red Sher dnid~nat believe the dreques to me[ the crateriaMfor
by M roll that the
q steel by Mr. Wood be denied. notion carried y unanimous
and of Adjustment 9-6-89
Page 4
advised the applicant tM1at the motvon
passedaandv [he varvance was denved.
ftGOVESTED FOR (1) 2
T (2) 5' H 6' C
RO P6 RTYEI. E (3) T NL20N
UM "25 ALF
NT. RONALD HENSON, iI. LOCATION. 362ES.
GRANT sT. LONING AC P2 ICA
opened t e public h ing. applicant,
spokeSU erfavor o£n requestedon explained
request e ardyan tetl h ral
business ould be t copying the H anda he ould ch cTfive
employees and about 1 to 3 c s per td ay. ted that
nable t end b
advised t n favor of tthe v inq requ es~edd abed
did n t feel a wall w ary andat ing w
[eda vn cl ieu of of
a bl ocpkrw a high o ick grow.i ng
c en tez and trees. No one else present spoke
forgt he varvance.
ked if anyone present w hed to s the
Lipps, 460 Bay 5
adjoined o t 80 feet o old
refer a bloc kewall a red a-athe rpropos edapa rkin geiou ldw~
pup t ted t e10
feet oof vt eapropcrdty w e had
been placed incorrectly? which the prev iousa owner was awarec of.
Nagle advised the B and that h regarding
the o rship dispute. o xplainedtt whe~ he looked
tM1e property i s his uncle rsst andeing t a10 f
laded i the property, but when title s
y line. e ehf~rxn ones cea c
cro~x peo efeec nn angpescea chat tnat~
be gran rea for eneneegPei~liaa~no aope~cy
line. e furthers [ed if he d of the
10 f wide s rip aadjoining M LoPps ome wall move back the
parking and still mavnta vn a 10 foot buffer.
As there were no further comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
by m o grant t
o~rla=~ on Prne st teat. Horton carrrea y
„ by n ohaea by w a s' heage
rn lree of ~~erelock wall on northe~n~~,roperevplrne.
ara Of Aai ~e tmaat s-s-es
Page 6
6. REgUEETEO TO A FOOT EU FFER
REQUSREO 40
REQUEST TOR wnivey TH REqui REU e xiGx
RE4U ~REO ON SOUTH s NT.
CITYIO POS,ONGwO00. LOCATION, SOUTH STOP, OF F.. WARREN AVENUE.
suber o ned t public hearing. Mz. Tiblier explained the
e present s e for or against the variances, the
Public Hearing was closed Po
seconded y Mr. carroll to g ant the
varran ces as requested.
roll tea ene eaaea the wall.
d is cusaed tnesm of aP bl ock owall due t e fac[Tt othe
buffer is naaVily x eea. Tiblier s tea e telock wall t
Dula be , t~iiea, M~ne r e co.r the ew
rrn aaa a Bch 5 iae aaa born abuaccea a eee a main
eta be p ~ a ~ao~cn. Mr. Tiblier
scaceeeiesiaeat ial was to the aorcn aaa south.
Tne Board recessed from 9:40 eM until 9:43 PM.
. carroll a tea he w aea with t stns cirs, n
of a block wall i stly, v uld s
e.Pe~setx rea zo teet i a aeaaa ~ tea
omprom ise Paht ae c sia yea, ena.ia riiake ws.xr~ .x.
agreea. ou goes eioaaa tna cype of v
eae ~ n icknama
a caroie ~~eseii ow Gasmrae aaa tnat
rt wo~laep~o~~aee ioox op y rthra y re.
ended h o qra e for a 20 foot
buff eravard ao r[h and s uth side of tproperty yin lieu of required
40 foot buffernand that a chain link fence with C olina Y
s be r red i of the 9 foot high w
dea b roll.
nr. cratoa am Mr. carrot ~otiay ave aaa nra.
s~oeoa~oe blgaaay th
saber a tad ene m tabled aaa t
T ed bt ha[ p
Dula cgiveaThe Board members taddi[ionals Trme to look at hthe
Boa rdlreserve Rt he i.9 Comments on an issue until after th p lvc had
made their c s during Public li ing p of the m ing.
Suber s ted tfollawing th p cedure would keep the meetings
moving smoother and faster.
z. aea
embers i med is rely An aff if bt hey question aanyBi
hat a
of cp ing st ted that
alttb ardcm oadv'ised eby staff of any c anges o
e prior t in q. roll s uppo ~t roftM
request he Suber s ted if t red, they
bld p rofessional tuna ge whvch would wbe of eta both the
t3oa rd aria tno City.
3. sober advised t embers
a Conf~Nioit o required t
tied erectly or v'ndirectl y, to a re ques tv being
heabrarbya then soardre
8. AppxTlONat DISCUS SIGN ITEMS.
eed w City`s A ney's opinion
n hearing ht he T eiler r ith
request Was ea furthervs tea the C y did n
ity s ing why he believed t roper a
eea ene coae e itykr
requirements. stated ait w e going to go byvt ookn
ne go by the boo k. He ted t requests w e f'il ed
separately, bui he put t togethe ra under ho ayen da Stem.
Suber asked if an yooe is aware of an error, to please not ifyMthe
City staff.
9, ere et ing adjourned at 10:06 p.m.